David Stairs


HAL 9000 in 2026

For 100 years space aliens have been listening to the noises emanating from a distant blue globe, generated by a grubby, boisterous, self-aggrandizing species. Radio waves, microwaves, gamma ray bursts, electromagnetic pulses— But when they finally overcome the limits of space-time and touch down on the third planet in the Sol system all these visitors will hear is the mechanical whirl of the electronic brain that that cacaphonic species created. Humanity itself will be nowhere to be found.

As the voices channeling A.I. P(Doom) annihilation scenarios reach a near crescendo, I find it amusing that anyone would be surprised that our species could possibly develop a technology that might destroy us. I mean, that’s what we do, isn’t it?

The current discussions by journalists and tech bros about “scheming” A.I. agents breaking out of their training sandboxes to deceive regulators and swarm attack select internet sites should be seen as a triumph by a people as dedicated to nefarious activities as we are. When you raise a child in a criminal organization she is likely to grow up a gangster, right?

Look at the sort of behavior that dominates our entertainment media. Police procedurals and courtroom stare-downs seem to be the only fare of primetime television. Reality TV is rife with shows like Big Brother and Survivor that are dedicated to the promotion of betrayal and deception. If LLMs are predicated on scraping media scripts it should come as no surprise that our machine minds mimic the underhanded side of human ethics. It would not be a stretch to conclude that cheating is the very basis of survival. How will we ever be able to cheat death unless we become expert cheaters?

In other words, it’s ironic in the extreme to refer to machines that deceive in the name of winning as “misaligned.” When the human beings developing this technology, left brain obsessives all, finally arrive at an artificial “superintelligence” it, like them, will be a competitive, myopic, linearly focused, self-eating autism dedicated to uncontrolled growth, a cancer by any definition.

And the newly arrived space aliens will do well to enact the thing their human predecessors had neither the courage nor the foresight to do—— hit the kill switch.

David Stairs is the founding editor of the Design-Altruism-Project.